Sorry Joan Acocella. You didn't answer the question. You talked about just about everything about New Yorkers *but* their rudeness. If this were 10th grade composition, you would have "See me" scrawled in red across the top of your paper.
So let me attempt an answer to this perennial question.
1) Because there are too many of us in a very small space.
There are a lot of us who live in the five boroughs. Add to that the throng of daily commuters. Now add all the toolbags who are moving here every day to either be a hedge-funder, a Scary Sadshaw or a Hipster. Let's turn it up a notch with a bunch of domestic tourists. Up some more with international tourists whose countries have a currency that is currently valued higher than the dollar. That's an assload of people in a very finite space. You think we're not crawling all over each other every second of the day? You do the math.
2) Because "I'm walking here!"
How would you like it if I invaded your living room every night and stood in front of the TV while you tried to watch 'My Name is Earl' from your barcalounger? Then don't gawk up at the tall buildings from the MIDDLE OF THE SIDEWALK. Really, it's just common courtesy, or were you raised by wolves? Step aside and look all you want - just don't do it in my path.
3) Because you're an idiot.
Here's where I agree with Acocella: New York is not considered the center of the universe for no good reason. People who come here generally have a little more going on in the IQ area, with a side order of ambition. We live in a fast-paced, global world. We read the paper and books (you remember books, right?). We like to discuss politics and world events. We have opinions about subjects other than what happened on 'The Hills' last night. So when you approach us on 42nd and Broadway asking where Times Square is, what else can we do but give you directions to Coney Island?
4) Because it's all in your head.
New York City has a long history of being a difficult place to live. Just rent 'Gangs of New York' or read Pete Hamill's 'Forever'. The muck and the puss and the stench and the goo one had to wade through just to get from point A to point B, never mind dodging people throwing the contents of their shitbuckets out the window. Unless you were an Astor, rolling around New York wasn't a pleasurable experience. Then came the Industrial Revolution and the place cleaned up a bit, with indoor plumbing and paved roads being two of the biggest contributors of a cleaner, nicer New York. The post-war years were a kind of Utopia (think Breakfast at Tiffany's), but unfortunately John Lindsay's disasterous tenure as mayor was fast on that era's heels and in no time the city was bankrupt, dirty and dangerous. Apparently everyone's impressions/memories of New York stop right here. Yes, people were pissy - wouldn't you be if your idea of a good week was no attempted muggings? Now we have Mayor Bloomie and things are nice, for better or for worse, and so are we. For the most part.
5) Because we just saw another Chase Bank being constructed in the place of our old favorite watering hole.
Enough said.
6) Because you do not stand clear of the closing doors.
Dudes, we know it's so cool that you're taking the subway for the VERY FIRST TIME, but your enthusiasm is getting in the way of our business. Get your ass in the car quickly, then sit down or hold onto something. We think it's totally gay when you shout out "Ooh!" while flopping onto some poor quotidian commuter because you got caught off guard by the jolt when the subway started moving. It's a subway. It jolts. I mean, what do you think this is, the Washington DC Metro?
7) Because NY is a culture where it's "all about me".
Some ass walking down the street on his cell phone elbow you in the septum? His didn't mean any malice in his bonking of your schnoz, it's just that you got in the way of his very important life. You should know better than to get in the way of his very important life. He is very important. Can't you gather that by the way he is talking about important things on the phone to another very important person?
8) Because we're too busy to be nice.
We're busy - we don't have time to help you. Except when we do. Per Acocella's column, there are times when New Yorkers are illogically nice, and it usually has to do with the giving of directions. I myself, possibly the most silently rude New Yorker there is (you should hear my inner monologue sometime) has on more than one occasion offered my assistance to an arguing couple holding a map. Once in French, even. Then there was that time I called 911 some dickhead smacking his wife around. I can be nice, but my niceness generally has a direct correlation with how far outside the NY metro area I happen to be.
In a nutshell, nice, nasty, bitchy or benevolent, all you need to know about the cross section of humanity that is New York you can find on Overheard in New York (this item is a particularly perfect example of the nice/rude dichotomy). Anyone planning a trip should bone up and buck up. It's going to be a bumpy ride.